A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, The Butch Huntress Gets Bit, Bewitched, and Betrayed, Pt 2
Paperback Confessions dives into Part 2 of A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, unpacking Tamlin’s Spring Court, the fire festival Calanmai, and Feyre’s first electric encounter with Rhysand. The hosts break down red flags, family secrets, and why Tamlin’s ”protection” looks a lot more like control — spoilers, spice, and swearing included.
Spoiler Warning
Heads up, confessors: this is a SPOILER-HEAVY episode. We're back in Prythian for Part 2 of our deep dive into A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, and we're getting into the Spring Court, Calanmai, a very memorable neck bite, and the moment G-Rex officially declared "fuck Tamlin" too.
If you haven't read A Court of Thorns and Roses, go finish crossing that wall before you press play, because we are not holding back.
The Book- Title: A Court of Thorns and Roses Series: Book 1 of the A Court of Thorns and Roses series
- Author: Sarah J. Maas
- Spice / Heat: Slow burn that finally catches fire — Calanmai, a possessive neck bite, and one very vanilla "I love you" that goes unanswered
- Tropes: Beauty and the Beast retelling, captor turned "protector," morally gray high lord, forbidden fire festival, the other man appears, glamoured secrets, love confessions nobody's ready for, and a heart of stone trying (and failing) to love somebody
Welcome back to the feral little sister of Sh!t That Goes On In Our Heads.
In Part 2, Feyre starts settling into Tamlin's estate — if you can call being glamoured, kept behind gates, and lied to about who else lives there "settling in." We meet Lucien (RIP to a real one; he catches every stray in this book), fall down the Tamlin-and-Lucien-are-definitely-a-couple rabbit hole, and unpack the fire festival Calanmai, where Feyre disobeys a very clear warning, meets a devastatingly hot stranger named Rhysand, and ends the night with Tamlin's teeth in her neck.
We also dig into Tamlin's tragic backstory, Lucien's tragic backstory, Feyre's suriel-delivered prophecy to "stay with the High Lord," and the introduction of Amarantha — sorry, Amaretto — the reason this whole curse exists in the first place. By the end, Tamlin sends Feyre home for her own "safety," she finds out her family's been living off his money the whole time, and Nesta — never glamoured, never fooled — cracks something open in Feyre that sends her right back across the wall.
Tamlin is officially past probation. He is in handcuffs.
Keywords: A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, ACOTAR, ACOTAR spoilers, Feyre Archeron, Tamlin, Rhysand, Lucien, Nesta Archeron, Prythian, Spring Court, Calanmai, fantasy romance podcast, fae romance, romantasy, Beauty and the Beast retelling, spicy book podcast, BookTok fantasy, Paperback Confessions
The Pour
This one basically pairs itself: an amaretto sour, because we cannot say Amarantha's name correctly and we're not going to start now. G-Rex is bringing the amaretto, Nacho's supplying the felt for the Amaretto doll craft project we did not plan to start mid-episode.
For a Calanmai-coded cocktail, go with something fire-toned — a spiced rum and blood orange situation with a cinnamon-stick garnish. Nonalcoholic confessors can stick with a spiced cider or a virgin amaretto sour (yes, that's a thing, look it up).
Just the TipIn Just the Tip, we get into whether Tamlin ever actually loved Feyre, or just loved what she could do for him.
Dirty Skittles' theory: he has a heart of stone and was never capable of loving her — just the idea of her, and the curse she could break.
Nacho pushes back a little, arguing Tamlin isn't intentionally controlling at first — he's doing what he thinks protection looks like, and it curdles the more Feyre pushes back.
G-Rex lands somewhere in the middle: fighter, not a lover, kind of a narcissist, but she gets why some readers — depending on how they were raised — might actually vibe with the "provider" thing he's selling.
On our Halos to Handcuffs scale, Tamlin is fully in handcuffs now. He glamours her, hides an entire population of people from her, locks her in during Calanmai "for her safety," and then sends her away the second she becomes inconvenient. He also tells her he loves her while actively trying to get rid of her. Sir. Ma'am. Whoever you are. This is not it.
What We Get Into- Lucien, the mask, and the curse Tamlin can't explain
- The great "are Tamlin and Lucien secretly together" theory
- Alis, the actual MVP of the Spring Court
- Fairies "can't lie" — a claim we do not trust
- The generational debate on whether Tamlin's whole vibe is romantic or a red flag
- Calanmai, the fire festival nobody explained properly
- Meeting Rhysand: "There you are. I've been looking for you."
- The neck bite heard 'round Prythian
- Lucien's Autumn Court backstory and his tragic scar
- Tamlin's brutal family and his "trying not to be like them" arc
- The suriel prophecy: stay with the High Lord
- The first (very vanilla) sex scene and the audiobook narrator's "Sarah, Sarah" problem
- The heads on spikes and the reveal that Rhysand put them there
- Rhysand crashing dinner, glamour or no glamour
- Introducing Amarantha, forever known as Amaretto
- Tamlin sending Feyre home "for her safety" (sure, Jan)
- Feyre coming home to a family living off Tamlin's money
- Nesta was never glamoured — and she went looking for Feyre
- The conversation with Nesta that finally cracks Feyre open
- Nacho: "I have enough felt to get this done."
- Dirty Skittles: "That is my favorite line I've ever heard you say."
- G-Rex: "Can we give him a bottle of amaretto dressed up like Emma— Amarantha?"
- Nacho: "May she be ever known, forever known as Amaretto."
- Dirty Skittles: "Fuck this guy anyways." (on Tamlin, repeatedly, and we mean it every time)
- Dirty Skittles: "He's like, fuck that guy, I got money now."
- G-Rex: "I got money around. I'm gonna go fucking spend it like it's the last thing on earth. I don't fucking care."
- Nacho: "We're so rich, we know we have three times what we had before."
- Nacho: "That would've sucked. Thank you, Sarah J. Maas."
- Dirty Skittles: "This is the part where I got hooked into the book — when I realized she's going back. That's when it got good."
G-Rex sees Tamlin exactly for what he is — a fighter, not a lover, and more than a little narcissistic — while admitting that if she'd been raised differently, the "let me provide for you and lock the gate behind you" energy might have landed differently. It doesn't for her.
Dirty Skittles came in hating Tamlin and leaves hating him more, convinced he's never once thought about what Feyre needs, only what he needs from her. Lucien, on the other hand, gets nothing but love — loyal to a fault, catching strays for a friend who doesn't deserve him.
Nacho holds a little more grace for early-Tamlin, arguing he's not trying to be controlling on purpose — he just doesn't know how to stop once Feyre stops fitting the shape he needs her to be. That grace runs out fast once Calanmai happens.
We agree on this much: Tamlin sent her away not to protect her, but to protect himself and the fantasy he built her into. And Nesta — messy, guarded, never glamoured Nesta — might be the one who actually gets through to Feyre.
Subscribe, Rate & ReviewSubscribe so you never miss an episode of Paperback Confessions, and rate and review us wherever you listen.
Every review helps more confessors discover our messy little book club.
Visit www.paperbackconfessions.com for episodes, bookish chaos, questionable fictional men, and everything else we probably should not be saying into microphones.
Coming Up NextIn Part 3, Feyre goes back across the wall — and straight Under the Mountain. We're getting into Amarantha's trials, Rhysand's real game, the true cost of loving someone with a heart of stone, and whether Feyre saves Tamlin or finally starts saving herself.
The masks are coming off. The curse is running out of time. And we are just getting started.
Yes, bitch.
#PaperbackConfessions #ACOTAR #ACourtOfThornsAndRoses #SarahJMaas #FeyreArcheron #Tamlin #Rhysand #Lucien #NestaArcheron #ElainArcheron #Prythian #SpringCourt #Calanmai #FaeRomance #FantasyRomance #Romantasy #BeautyAndTheBeast #SpicyBooks #BookTok #Bookstagram #FantasyBooks #BookPodcast #RomancePodcast #FuckTamlin #HeartOfStone #Amaretto
Where to Find Us
Website: https://www.paperbackconfessions.com
Instagram: @paperback_confessions
Paperback Confessions is the feral sister podcast to the award-winning Sh!t That Goes On In Our Heads, where we normalize conversations about mental health through honest stories, laughter, and real connection.
Discover more at: https://goesoninourheads.net
00:01 - Welcome Back to Prythian
01:07 - Tamlin’s True Face and the Golden Mask
03:03 - Is Tamlin a Good Guy? The Debate Begins
04:33 - The Lucien and Tamlin Theory
06:12 - Meet Alis, the MVP
06:48 - Feyre’s First Feast
08:01 - Can Fae Really Not Lie?
08:51 - Side Quest: Generational Takes on Tamlin
12:07 - Protection or Control?
16:48 - A Fractured Beauty and the Beast
18:15 - The Truth About Who’s Really There
18:51 - Calanmai: The Fire Festival
21:40 - Enter Rhysand
23:01 - The Neck Bite
25:09 - Lucien’s Tragic Backstory
29:39 - Tamlin’s Brutal Family
31:02 - The Suriel’s Prophecy
33:44 - Did Tamlin Ever Really Love Her?
37:52 - Heads on Spikes and Rhysand’s Return
41:51 - Meet Amarantha (aka Amaretto)
44:33 - Tamlin Sends Feyre Away
47:16 - Lucien Begs for More Time
50:10 - Coming Home to a Different Life
51:28 - Nesta Was Never Glamoured
53:37 - The Conversation That Changes Everything
0:01 Hey listeners, you're about to hear part 2 of our coverage of A Court of Thorns and Roses. The romance is blooming, but so is the danger. Feyre's heart is being tested, secrets are unraveling, and every choice she makes pulls her closer to a battle she never asked to fight. Let's head back to the Prythian and see just how much she is willing to sacrifice.
0:52 You know, I think as it's being described, so he's the, we find out he's the High Lord of the Spring Court. And when I heard how this was described of like flowers and greenery and hills and like, just, it's spring, it's beautiful, it's gorgeous, it's wonderful. Mm-hmm. I thought of Elaine. Like, I was like, oh yeah, this is like that. This would be her vibe. Oh God. Found that a little interesting. Um, oh no. Oh no. Oh, what, what did I just trigger in you? No. Every time I hear a theory that's even remotely plausible about everything, I'm just like, oh, I have so many theories on Tamlin. Goddamn it. We're gonna, we, I'm, that gorgeous brain is just gonna let it all out. But yeah, Spring Court sounded like Nesta's vibe. Like she would've been— Elaine. Sorry.
1:46 Elaine's vibe. Under the Mountain is Nesta's vibe. Um, it was her vibe. Ah, so much of it is her vibe. But she's there, she's starting to figure out who's this, this person. The monster now transforms into his fairy self, who is like this handsome, gorgeous guy, uh, with like blonde hair, I think. Doesn't matter. But he's wearing a mask, like a gold mask over his face. Mm-hmm. And she, I think, originally thinks like, oh, he's just trying to keep some sort of like anonymity of like who he is. Like she doesn't understand, or she's like, oh, maybe it's like a fashion choice.
2:26 Fucking hilarious. But like, she doesn't know that that mask is part of this curse that he has. Um, he can't take it off, which is fucking super funny, honestly. It's like a beautiful, gorgeous, intricate mask part of it. Anyways, um, we, we start to see him. I think he Is still pretty much a dick and an asshole for a while. Uh, eventually he softens up, I guess, as much as an asshole could soften up. Um, but we meet the other character, Lucien. I love Lucien. So both of you have been telling me like, fuck Tamlin, fuck Tamlin, fuck Tamlin. It took me a while to get to that fuck Tamlin part.
3:14 Because I did see how he was trying to take her under his wing. And even though he was an asshole about it, almost kind of like a little narcissistic about it, he was— Skittles has broken! He— it would— it's like I said, it took me a while to figure out that he was a dick. But, um, like, I just liked how he matched her, like Butch energy. Does that make sense? Okay. How so? This is why, this is why, G, because, because we've read the books and, and this is not as bad as it gets for him. Okay. So it's important for you to say what you think, knowing what you know.
4:08 So to me, he's more of a fighter than a lover. Right. He is all about being a badass and being like, I'm the ruler of this land and my shit don't stink. And like, for the longest time, I swear to God, I thought Lucien and Tamlin were like, like together. Same, right? And who's to say that they're not? We don't know for sure that they're not. It wasn't written in the book and it made me really sad. And I'm gonna tell you who's gonna be the top and who's gonna be the bottom in that relationship. Lucien is definitely on the receiving end of Tamlin. Oh yeah, with pleasure. With pleasure. With pleasure.
4:52 Like little pointy ears and everything. He's like back there just grabbing onto his ears and be like, ride him, cowboy. Okay, I'm sorry, I broke Nacho. That, that's how I like read into the book. I was like, okay. maybe, maybe this is how this plays out. But of course it doesn't, because, you know, fantasy is never fucking reality. But, um, my whole take on Tamlin is, yes, fighter, not a lover, kind of a narcissist. Lucien was kind of a pussy, didn't really stand up for her, kind of like, you know, towards the end of the book he starts to stand up for her, but that's how I see it. I also thought Lucien and Tamlin were lovers. So Lucien is what we learned to basically be Tamlin's bestie. Yeah. They're best friends. They are, um, Lucien's his like mercenary.
5:53 So he's— He's literally, as far as Feyre knows, the only other person besides Alis, right? It's Alis, right? Yep. Mm-hmm. Um, the only other person In the, in the whole world. Yeah. Castle. Yeah. Or whatever mansion, whatever with him. Yeah. That's, that's a good point. 'Cause she gets there and there's like nobody, there's beautiful lands, but it's, it's Tamlin, Lucien, and Alice. Alice is the housekeeper. What do we call her? Yeah. House person. House person. She takes care of Feyre while she's there. She like helps. That's very non-binary of you, G. Um, I love Alis. I love Alis. She's, she's the MVP of the story, really. Here we go. There we go. We're breaking her good now. I'm gonna wet my pants. I told you, pull out the punny pad.
6:48 But I, I do have to say that I think that Feyre was able to bring out her butch side and her femme side a little bit more once she moved in with like Tamlin and Lucien. And I— one of the things that did make me happy is like when she went to that first breakfast and that first meal, that was more food than she'd ever seen in her entire life, right? Yeah. And so something that would like soothe her soul, but she missed her family and she's in this like crazy realm And they all have masks on, so she can't see their true faces. She can only see like their lips and their ears and their, their hands and eye color.
7:35 Eye color. So for me, I, I would be a little fucking weirded out. Yeah. And she also has all these like preconceived notions of fairies. So she like sees the food and she's starving. And to your point, it's like an abundance, but she's believing that if she eats their food, that they'll like drug her. So she's afraid to sort of be that free to have those types of, to even just eat. Yeah. Yeah. So it takes her a while. And then she also believes, ooh, fuck Tamlin. She also believes that fairies can't lie. So Tamlin— We're gonna go through this episode and I'm gonna have a counter. Yeah. And I can't wait. Yeah. I can't wait. Let's have a counter. Don't, Don't hide 'em. Let 'em go.
8:20 But the problem is, we're gonna side quest back to the tailman thing cuz somebody in my life has a very, very interesting perspective. Okay. And I do wanna voice it for any listener who might be in that same belief. But, um, she also believes fairies can't lie. And so he tells her the food is safe, you can eat here. So she has to trust that this guy can't lie. They can, they can lie. And I'm not saying the food was drugged, but like they for sure can lie. Um, the side quest is somebody in my life. I think any listener or reader, you either love Tamlin or you hate Tamlin. I don't see how you love— okay, well, if you've read more than one book, I don't see how you like Tamlin, but okay. Um, but the world is divided and this person in my life who I love and respect loves Tamlin and I'm like, what? Like, what the fuck?
9:08 Wait, like, like they've read more than one book? Yeah, they've read 'em all. And I'm like, how do you love Tamlin? And their theory, or I guess how they see it, is that from their generation, this is got the kind of guy you would have. And in my opinion, yeah, Tamlin, the reason part of like the core of why I hate this motherfucker is because he wants Feyre to fit a role. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. He doesn't believe that, I would argue any woman could be of high ranking, uh, could be a protector, could be a provider. And that's all Farrah has ever been is like a protector, provider, a hunter. Like she's out there and he doesn't believe that that is the role of a woman. And to the point where, oh, he is stifling her to just fit what he needs her to be. And so that's why I hate this guy. But this person in my life feels like in their generation, that was the role of a woman, was to be at home. Yeah. Dress in the dresses, host the parties. Yeah.
10:22 You know what? So the, the person you're thinking about, I, I, I grew up in that same generation, maybe a few years later. But that's not how I saw my role as a woman, to be a provider. And it could be because of how I was raised, right? Like I was raised to— I think that has a lot to do with it. A strong, independent woman that can fend for myself and take care of myself. And I think when you're reading the book, it's all on how you were raised. Of how you would view Tamlin, for sure. Yeah, absolutely. I think that if you were, 'cause I see how this could feed into some of the people in my life and they would feel the same way, maybe. Like if it was, God rest her soul, my grandmother, and we didn't have that like little spot, she probably would've loved it. She probably would've loved it. Oh, Tamlin's taking care of her. Tamlin's being so sweet. Tamlin's doing the right providing.
11:29 And, and he's, you know, gentle with her, but he's also vicious when it comes to time to, to, you know, protect what's theirs. And he wants her to be, you know, so absolutely. Yeah. Absolutely. I can see why I could see why there are people out there that might vibe with that whole reality. I love a good, like, Strong protector moment, but also you have to be able to like let people live their life. Yes. Yeah. And I, and then like, it pains me cuz like it goes, it goes so against everything that I am.
12:14 Mm-hmm. So to hear that perspective, like, I know it logically, I could understand it, but like The core and essence of my being is like, no. The part of you that wasn't raised in a way that keeps you mindful of the idea that men are the end-all and be-all. Yeah. And are only allowed to be a certain way. And I think that puts it in a nutshell, like how Tamlin is with Feyre is he is— I don't think he's intending, I don't think he's like intending to do the things at the beginning. I don't think he's intentionally trying to be like a controlling, manipulative asshole. I think he's actually trying to do what he thinks is the right thing to do.
13:11 And the more that Feyre grows. And the more that she pushes back on that, the more he tries to push further into the ideal that he wants to achieve. And so then he starts using and going further and going harder into what he wants and what he needs. And then that's where they lose each other because he's only concerned with what he needs. and what he wants, and he stops listening to her. But that's like, that's like another book. That's not this book. Well, and this could be 100% my bias. I don't think he ever— okay, hold on. I think he always wanted what he needed. I don't think he ever really thought about her in what she needs. I think, and again, I hate this motherfucker, but I feel like he, it was a gift to be with him. And that's all he believes. Any female with me, you're welcome. Like, I am the High Lord of the Spring Court. I need you, Feyre, to break this curse.
14:23 But I don't think it went farther than that. I think— Nope. I think he always just, okay. This is so hard to articulate cuz I think, um, his protective nature for her where he's like, no, don't come with me. So he like goes and he like, uh, fights some of the evil, like monstrous characters that come onto his land and he wants her to stay back for her protection. You know, you're a human. This is really dangerous. Even though I'm a human that killed a, a fairy with one ash arrow. But you know, whatever. Right, right. But in the beginning it's like, oh, this is nothing compared to the the wolf fairy you killed. Like, no, you need to stay back. I'm protecting you. He's like making her believe, I'm protecting you. I need you to stay here. But in my mind, I'm like, he needed her to be safe because he needs her to break his curse. So he's not willing to risk anything to take that away. I think towards— and I think he kind of like conditions her to sort of feel like he is my protector. He wants the best for me. What a great high lord. Like, he is just the cat's pajamas. Like, he's amazing. He's handsome. He's protecting me. Look at— he's giving me all this food, this beautiful house. I'm not a prisoner. I can walk his grounds.
15:45 Don't go past the fucking gates, but I can go anywhere else. I'm not a prisoner. Look at me. Yeah. But then you vibe with that whole, like, the same idea and okay. Okay. Okay. But then you have the holiday. And he's all like, oh, this is just a thing that I have to do. Ugh. I just have to go have sex. This is just a thing I have to go do. Fuck this guy. And I'm like, he kind of loses me there because at first I was like, uh, all right. It's like a, like a Beauty and the Beast kind of a thing. Oh. And he's just an asshole. And you know, we have a side quest on that too, but oh, good. Let's bring it. Let's do it. So like, that's why I was trying, cuz I was like, I was trying to get into it cuz one of my other book besties, uh, for life is like, you have to read this.
16:35 And so I was trying really hard just to like get through. I was trudging along. So I was like, okay, maybe, maybe it's like a Beauty and the Beast thing cuz I have to like have expectations in a book to be like, keep going. Right? Yeah. What were you gonna say, G? Yeah, same, same thing. I, you know, I read it as like Beauty and the Beast, but like a fucked up version of Beauty and the Beast. Yeah, I thought we were going like Anne Rice, right? Like super, super fucked up. But like the whole, like the sequences of like her like finding her own way on this land, right? Lucien telling her to go And capture this, this screaming— Serial. Mimi, whatever the fuck we want to call it, and trying to get, trying to get like the truth out of that. And then how she was gonna try and sneak back in and go and see her father and sister, and like creepy fucking shit was coming out. And like, but didn't he, didn't they glamour, didn't they glamour her also? So like she couldn't see the other— Anybody else. Anybody else. She only saw those, like, how fucking fucked up is that? Yeah. So yeah, he glamours her. So she only believes all that is there, like Nacho said, is Tamlin, Lucien, and Alis, that there is nobody else on this land. Fast forward to like when the book started to get really interesting, she, she starts to see that there are other people there. They have
18:08 always been there. He just hid them from her. Why do you think that is? I, I think it's because they, they wanted to, they didn't want her to, they wanted to make her still feel like she was held, being held captive. Right. And that she didn't have any choices. I, I don't know. No, I don't think so. No, I don't think so. Yeah. I don't think he wanted her to talk to anybody else. I, 'cause that's what I, that's what this was, uh, under the thumb, man. Under the thumb. Yeah. You're not like, you don't see them, they don't exist. You are the only thing. Because he really fucking loses me at Cal and Mai. Okay. So let's get to Cal and Mai. Cal and Mai is this weird fucking— Oh, oh, this is so fucked up. It's so fucked up. So you remember how I called Sean the granola eating motherfucker in Ravenhood? Yeah. So as I was like reviewing this book, I was like, Tamlin is the fiddle-playing motherfucker because in Kalanmai, he's just like, here's how I imagine it in my brain, right? You got this, he's like a Fabio-looking kind of character, right? Like tall, broad, muscular, ripped, long flowing locks, a gold mask, sweat bleeding off his skin, and he's just playing the fucking fiddle. Yes.
19:31 Yeah. Like, like Devil Goes Down to Georgia. Yeah. Around a fire. He's just, fuck this guy anyways. But Calamite, to, to what Nacho was getting towards earlier, is like beforehand, I don't remember if it was him or Lucien that tells her like, hey, heads up, we're about to have this bomb-ass party outside and you may hear music and see lights and there's gonna be food and people, but like, you need to stay here. Yeah. You can't come out. Like, what the fuck? It's for your safety. Stay inside. Um, also, if you don't stay inside, Tamlin becomes a raging horny motherfucker and he needs to have sex with somebody tonight. And if he smells you and can get to you, he's gonna fuck you in a way that you're not gonna like. So stay inside.
20:18 That immediately would've just perked up my ears and been like, mm, okay. Oops. Oops. Here I am. Hi. My bad. Hi, I'm here. Yeah. So, uh, spoiler alert, she doesn't stay inside. Uh, she, she makes her way there and she like gets stopped by these 3 Brutuses. Yeah. 'Cause Calamite, she like goes to get food outta the kitchen 'cause she's so hungry. 'Cause FYI, all the food's at the party. And she's left in the house with no food. 'Cause Cal and Maia is just for spring court. It's like, um, he has to have sex with somebody so like their crops survive or something. Yeah. Okay. So she goes outside, she sees faeries lined up. Tamlin apparently has his pick of the, the litter. He's gonna fuck somebody tonight.
21:15 Um, as she's out there. A bunch of fairy males, I guess, sniff her out and they're like, ooh, human, go fuck this girl. And she's like, oh no, what am I gonna do? Nobody's here to protect me, my Tamlin. And instead she meets a character called Rhysand, and his first words to Feyre are, there you are. I've been looking for you. Uh, foreshadowing. Foreshadowing. And she's like, whoa, who's that? Remember that this guy is the sexiest fucking guy I've ever seen in my life. Complete opposite of Tamlin. He's not wearing a mask. He has dark hair. He has these beautiful blue slash violet eyes. He is tall, dark. It looks like there's shadows caressing him. He just appears outta nowhere.
22:10 And the fairy guys that are trying to fuck Feyre are like, whoa, we're getting outta here. This guy's, he's something. And they leave. He's scary. Yeah. He scares them away. And so I think she becomes wary of like, oh my God, who's this guy? And then he proceeds to be like, hey, why are you out here? You know, like, what, what you doing, girl? And she's like, oh no, I'm here with my friends. And he's like, well, they just left you alone here. Like, that sounds like not a good friend. Maybe you should stay out of trouble. Uh, then Lucien kind of comes. I think he like runs her back to the house and he's like, you gotta hide yourself, Tamlin's gonna smell you and fuck you.
22:51 Yeah. Me and my Cliff Notes. Dude, your Cliff Notes are spann— handled. Mic drop. Uh, yeah. Tamlin finds her. I think it was after the party though. Like there was like remnants of this beast, but he's already fucked somebody else. So yeah, apparently he can only fuck one person one night. So she has to settle with him biting her neck and it's hot. You know? It, it is hot. It was like, I, I thought for sure at that, that point that they were gonna like do it. Yeah. But like, he was just, he was brutal. Okay. He, he reminds me of like a mean fucking drunk or an abusive husband. Mm-hmm. Like, you don't fucking do that shit. Okay. You, you just don't, you don't do it in real life and doing it in smutty books. I mean, it's okay, but fuck you. Like, fuck off. Yeah, it's okay in smutty books. Gee, it's okay in smutty books. We're okay. In smutty books. But like, I fucking— This is not your first bite. You will get more bites. And as a lesbian, like, if a woman did that to me, I'm gonna kick you in the pussy. Exactly. Okay? And I'm not gonna fucking think twice about it.
24:06 Don't fucking edge G. She'll kick you right in the pussy. Don't fucking edge her. I will kick you in the cooter and not even think twice about it. I do not have time for this shit. If you're gonna bite my neck, you better be biting someplace else too. Like you said, Ellie, or don't even come over here. All in or get the fuck out. Like, bring your furry little paw and like give me some other action. Just don't bite my fucking neck because now I'm like bruised up and I'm horny as fuck. Thanks. I will say, all right, what I appreciated— Nacho is dead. Well, because Nacho— I don't know if it was the kick kicker in the pussy comment or cook the cooter. I don't know. Doesn't matter.
24:55 Okay, okay, my face hurts. I love it. Gee, I don't think I— I love it. I love it. Okay, okay, go ahead. Uh, I was gonna say, I think the best part of the neck bite was, uh, Lucien's reaction to— reaction to it in the morning. He kind of gives them a hard time. He's like, oh, what happened to your neck? And Tamlin's like, oh, I bit her. And like, they kind of like fuck around back and forth on it. Uh, side note, I think Lucien's probably one of my favorite characters in book 1, cuz he's like underrated, right? Like, Yeah. Lucien has like this fucking gnarly scar over his eye. He also has like a mechanical eye. It's not a, it's not like a normal eyeball, so you're kind of like, through book 1 are like, oh my God, what the fuck happened to him? Right? Like, where's his eye? Um, and Lucien's like this loyal friend to Tamlin, but he's also kind of an asshole. Like he enjoys fucking with Feyre.
25:59 Um, he's like a, it was like a brother-sister relationship where he's just like nagging on her and like fucking doing mean shit, but it's funny. Um, so I like— I totally thought there was gonna be a 3-way here. Insert all the way. I thought, cuz you were talking about how you were Thinking that Lucien and, and Tamlin, I was like, oh, here we go, here we go. I wanted there to be— there's got to be fanfic out there. But like, how do you have sex with somebody's like metal eye that's still like fucking rolling around in their head? They're not having sex with the eye, dude. But you still gotta look at the face. No, you don't. You can close your eyes or roll over. Are we like On all fours? Am I facing the backboard? I just don't know. However you want it. Just, I mean, whatever. You just let your fupa cover it.
26:55 It's fine. Just close your eyes, babe. Wait, your eye— what is that cold metal thing on my back? Did your eye just pop out? You just hear like he can't see shit. Not now. Look at me later. Like a booty. It's fallen and I can't get up. Okay. Oh my God. Oh, that's twice. Twice we've broken Nacho. Sorry, sorry, Dirty Skittles. I know you're trying to be serious, but we can't. No, I love this shit. I love it. I, the, but he's like one of my favorite characters and I, and I feel for him. Yeah. 'Cause especially in this book, he catches so many strays. Lucien gets fucked so many times in this book. Mm-hmm. Just trying to be a loyal friend to Tamlin.
27:54 And I'm like, this poor fucking guy. He's like loyal to a fault and it makes him make shit choices because that's his best friend. That's his high lord. Like he, he. He's just loyal to his family. Oh yeah. 'Cause he owes, he owes, I mean, yeah, he, he says he owes Tamlin. Yeah. For all the things. And I, and we do find out in this book, some backstory to Lucien is that he is from the Autumn Court, which one of my favorite seasons. Um, he basically gets kicked out of his family. After they torture and kill the love of his life and make him watch, they make Lucien watch what they're doing. They off his love and kick him out of the court and Tamlin takes him in.
28:45 Don't worry. I mean, they, they make him watch them brutally murder. Yeah. The love of his life. Yeah. And when he had both of his eyes. Fucking asshole. And then has a metal one like rolling around in his head. Yeah. No. I should have taken a gummy before this. Oh, oh, poor Lucian, you know. So like, he, he, he owes that to the camera. This is when he had both of his eyes. When he had both of his— Now in my brain is camera 1, camera 2, camera 1. Camera, camera work. Camera team. Um, so yeah, he, I love Lucien. Bless his heart.
29:31 He meant well. Oh no, not bless his heart. Speaking of hearts though. Oh no. Um, so we learned that about Lucien. We also learn a little bit of Tamlin's story and why he's such a fucking asshole, I guess. Uh, he, his dad and his brothers are all like brutal. Yeah. Um, killed a bunch of people, people that'll come back and are characters that anyways killed a bunch of people. Um, also I think they like would take like humans as slaves and treat them like shit too. So like, yeah, Tamlin sort of has this inner struggle. Like he doesn't wanna be like his dad or his brothers, but he very much has an agenda.
30:15 So in my opinion, His only— he goes the route of keeping her as a prisoner, as a slave, because that's kind of what he's seen his fathers and his brothers do. But he's trying to do it without like the mentality that she's doing. Yeah. He's trying to be not a, not as be as like assholes that his family was. Yes. And some of the people that they kill— oh, is this in book 1? Yeah. Probably not. Probably not. Okay. Think about where we end. Do we know about it before? That's why I was like, uh, anyways, we, we can always reference back. He's made enemies. There we go.
30:59 He's made enemies. Yeah. Um, because his family has brutally murdered other families. Mm-hmm. So he has enemies. Um, Anyways, all of that to say that eventually at some point, Lucien continues to fuck around with Feyre, but she's able to— he sends her off on a mission. Um, he teaches her how to snag a surreal, which is a creature. Mm-hmm. And she's a huntress. So her G.I. Jane comes back out and she fucking nails it. She, she snags this thing. Uh, the Suriel starts to tell her kind of her future, sort of. One of the lines it tells her, and I think this is important because it makes her become that role Tamlin wants, is that this creature tells her that you have to stay with the High Lord. Stay with the High Lord. And so that's like, in Feyre's mind, oh, Tamlin, he'll protect me. I have to stay with him. And so she begins to sort of fit into that role that Tamlin needs and wants her to be in.
32:05 And they start to develop feelings for one another, sort of. I say sort of, cuz I question whether or not Tamlin ever really felt anything for her because he has a heart of stone. Yes, he does. So how do you, how do you love someone when you have a heart of stone? Is it always mental? 'Cause that's what I went through. So I'm curious. How is he getting an erection if he's got a heart of stone? 'Cause I don't think you gotta feel with your heart to get hard for— Do you know what I mean? No, but you have to have blood pumping, right? That is the science of the— Okay. You know what? It's all right. It's like, it's like, it's like Lisa the lesbian and like how she like fucks up every Hollywood movie I watch. Like, how do they do that? I'm like, it's the fucking movies, okay?
32:56 So this is a book. Wait, did I fuck it up or did Nacho fuck it up? Nacho's fucking this up. Nacho fucked it up. It's a, it's a book. So like, maybe because they're— it's half man, half animal, maybe they're— I mean, it's a different way. Maybe, I don't know, maybe we get an erection by like just thinking about it. I know many men that An erection just fucking thinking about it. You know, like they don't even have to touch that shit. That's my theory. My wild fucking theory as Dirty Skittles is that this fucking piece of shit guy never loved her because he couldn't. He could never fucking love her. He always wanted her for a purpose. And maybe he was in love with the idea of her, but never really her. Yeah. Damn. And, and to the opposite, Feyre sees him as he saved her from the life she had. So yeah, he's protecting her.
33:53 She's now being reaffirmed to stay with the High Lord. So she just falls into that role. And that's when, like, she kind of opens up the possibility of sort of flirting and letting this kind of progress because that's what I should be doing now. And they eventually— Dude, to be quite honest, I don't even remember the first time they had sex cuz I hated it so much because it was so like sweet and yeah, with a character I hated, I couldn't get past it. So do you remember? Yeah, it was very, very vanilla and very like what I imagined sex would look like with somebody from that. With a lion.
34:37 Frame of mind. No, not sex with the lion, dude. Could you imagine? Oh, they bite on you, don't they? On the back. Well, you know, or just sex with a cat. You know, they're nice rough tongues. Hey, I wish I was purring for sure. Everybody wants a rough tongue every now and then. But I, you know, I do see your point where She, she saw him as a savior, right? But I also kind of like looked at it from, from my lens as like, you know, there's certain points in times in my life where like I just needed somebody to sweep me up and like fucking take care of me because apparently I can't take very good care of myself. Hmm. But at the same time, there's a price to pay for that, right? Yeah. Getting locked away in this motherfucking house and like 2 crazy dudes with masks on it. on them.
35:34 And— Usually that's a great start to a book. And not being able to leave the lands, but like you have Lucien telling her, like sending her all these fucked up quests and, you know, kind of hoping that she doesn't die, but like kind of in the back of his head, he's like, I don't know if she's gonna survive this. And then you have Tamlin who's very possessive, right? And it's like, you can't do this. You blah, blah, blah. Fuck you, dude. Listen. Yeah. I'm gonna do what I wanna do when I wanna fucking do it. Bring me some motherfucking food and quit being a dick. It, he was like a, remember the animal in Dr. Dolittle, the push me, pull me?
36:15 He reminded me a lot of like push me, pull me. Hmm. Yeah. I just hated him off the jump. I don't know. I did. I did. And it, and it, it got worse as the series went on. Um, yeah, but yeah, it's an interesting dynamic. They, they eventually start to have feelings for one another. They have sex at some point. I, I'll be honest, listeners, I, I don't remember the sex. I just remember it was very vanilla to Nacho's point. Um, like kissing and touching. And I hated, uh, if you've listened to the audio version, I hated the way the, the audio actor like says her name during sex and how like that just like lights her up. I fucking hated it all. It was just, yeah, he's like, oh, Sarah. Sarah.
36:56 Sarah. Yeah, it's like, ugh, gross. Yeah, gross. Okay. Sorry, I'm bad. No, no, it just, it wasn't my vibe, bro. Like it just wasn't, it wasn't my fucking vibe at all. Um, and I think the other thing, like kind of as, as we get to what I think is the good part is the whole time Feyre is learning that there is a sickness in the lands. Yeah. And so Tamlin has to protect his Spring Court, uh, from this sickness entering in. And, you know, at times there are these intruders in the land. And one of the times that she kind of sees it is when these heads of fairies are put on spikes. And I think at like the entrance of the Spring Court.
37:52 Yes. And it's revealed then, well, it's revealed a little later on that the person responsible for putting those faeries' heads on spikes is Rhysand, the mysterious dark figure she meets during Fire Night. And that's when we start to see that Rhysand and Tamlin hate each other. There is a deep hate. But okay. She doesn't know his name, but she recognizes the face. He comes back to the Spring Court to check up on Tamlin and Tamlin, Lucien, and Feyre are eating and, ah, bless Lucien. Love him. Stands in front of Feyre, kind of pushes her against the wall, but he's standing in front of her. Tamlin glamours her so she's invisible. Oh yeah. Rhysand comes into the dining room. That's when we kind of find out that he's the one that put the fairy heads out front and, uh, Rhysand's an asshole, so naturally I love him. Um, cuz he's just like, oh, you didn't like my gift? Thought it was— thought you'd love it. It's like deadheads on sticks.
39:01 Um, when I first imagined Rhysand in my head, what came up was the licorice guy from Candyland. I'm gonna Google this. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't know why, but that's the, that's the imagery that came into my brain. That would've ruined the book for me, Nacho, if I pictured disgusting. I read this after Fourth Wing, so I saw Xaden. That's who I pictured. I was like, oh, it's Xaden. Yeah, same here. Mm-hmm. Um, and again, I'm a sucker for dark hair, light eyes. So I was like, yep, sign me up. Uh, true. Uh, but yeah, he comes into the dining room, they glamor Feyre, they're hiding her. He's, I don't remember if he's just there to check in on Tamlin or, or he's there to say, like, I don't remember the purpose, but we, we find out that there's another player in place here that wants Tamlin. To basically bow down and, and come, like they're coming to get Tamlin essentially. And Rhysand is the collector. And while they're there, Rhysand's about to leave and notices, oh wait, there's 3 place settings on this table, but there's only 2 people here. So he asks and Lucien takes another stray. He's like, that's— they've already left. Rhysand figures out— Look at G.
40:29 Go ahead, G. So Rhysand can also like read, read memories and read minds. Yeah. And so he knew, even though she was glamoured, he knew she was in there. And so he's like already in her mind. He, he gets pissed cuz he's like, you fucking glamoured me, dude. He's like, fuck you. And then he can see Feyre. Yeah. And he is like, oh, he recognizes her. Uh-huh. Um, Lucien goes, that's my betrothed. He's like, that's my woman, back up. Right. And to, to protect Feyre, but really to protect Tamlin because Tamlin needs Feyre. So no, this is my girl. Like, don't even pay her any mind. And Rhysand can go into Feyre's mind cuz that's one of his powers.
41:16 Um, and I think he's like hurting, not hurting her, but like She's frozen still. It fucks Tamlin up cuz he doesn't want her to be hurt, hurt. And immediately he's a bitch, right? What does he fucking do? Just like, just like everybody else in Feyre's life. He like drops, like Rhysand's like, get on your knees then. Cuz he's like, please don't tell, um, Amarantha that Feyre is here. Like, please, please, please. Rhysand's like, cool, beg, you know, beg for it. Immediately Tamlin's on his knees. begging Rhysand, please, please. And, um, Rhysand I think asks her at that point, what's your name? She gives some other person's name, Claire, some bullshit. I don't know. Yeah. Claire, her, the, the girl that ended up sleeping with, um, the guy that she was sleeping with. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. She's like, it's Claire Better or whatever the fuck. And Ray-san's like, all right, works for me. I think that's where— and, and that's where the book starts getting really fucked up, right? And like, I can't say that, that Emma, whatever, I just call her Amaretto. Amaretto. I love it. Because I can't even say it. May she be ever known, forever known as Amaretto. Amaretto.
42:39 Oh. Because the more you have of her, the more fucked up you get. Can I tell you my dad loves Amaretto? Oh, really? Yeah. Like the drink, not the character? Well, correct. Okay. I was like, oh, he likes her. Yeah. Yeah. My whole life, Amaretto. I, I like that little Amaretto di Serrano, the square. Yeah. I do like that too though. That is really good. It's so good. It's like, you know, that's like a treat. Jergens, that Jergens cherry almond, uh, lotion from like in the whatever. Uh, that's what it, I imagine it would taste like. It, it would taste like is amaretto. Can we give him a bottle of amaretto dressed up like Emma, Emma with a— Amarantha. Amarantha. Yeah. Can we make a little doll out of it for him? Yeah. We, you know what? I have enough felt to get this done.
43:33 That is my favorite line I've ever heard you say. I have enough felt to get this done. I have enough felt to get this done. She held up a finger. She goes, uh-huh. I have enough felt to get this done. Huzzah! I have enough felt in a rainbow of colors. I love it. She gets this done. Can we make it a school project? Yeah. Do we want to like just do it together or do you just want me to send you pictures? You can send me pictures while I'm fucking dying of laughter. I'm gonna make it look like the licorice, the licorice guy from Candyland, but with amaranth all over it. That would've ruined this. I couldn't. Yeah. That would've ruined it for me. Um, all right. To the liquor store I go.
44:16 I'll, I'll buy the amaretto. You, you, you supply the felt. Love it. Um, so yeah, Tamlin's a bitch. He's on his knees. He's begging like, please don't do this. Rhysand gets this name, Clare. He's like, sweet, good enough. I'm out. He leaves. Uh, fast forward, Tamlin is now full-on bitch mode. tells Feyre, you've gotta go. You can't be here. You're not safe anymore. I can't keep you safe anymore. You have to leave. Now, my question for you guys is, do you think in that moment he wants her to leave because he feels that, like, I can't keep you safe, you've really gotta go? Like, do you think he's doing that to protect her and take care of her?
45:01 I don't know. In his twisted little fucking mind, he is. Yeah, I think that he thinks he's doing the right thing. I think he's trying to save him, save himself, because having Feyre there is just putting a target on his back. So he's trying to protect himself. I don't think he really ever gave two shits about her, but it was like his little prize, and now it's time for him to send his little prize off. Okay. So. This, um, curse for the listeners, they're, they are days away from his deadline. You have 50 years or whatever the fuck it is. Hmm.
45:42 And if you can't get a human to fall in love with you by this time, you are mine. Amaretto wants Tamlin. Amaretto. You belong to me. Days away from that happening, he tells Feyre, you gotta go. I can't keep you safe anymore. You've gotta go back home. Uh, they make love, bury Feyre in her neck. It's fucking gross. Um, and he tells her, I love you. My favorite part is she's like, uh, uh, great. Mm-hmm. She's like, oh, okay. Thanks. Yeah. And he says it again and again and again. She doesn't respond.
46:27 Eventually they tire. Just told her that she had to leave to try to get it out of her. Yes. So that he could have— Fucking do. That's my theory. I was like, yo, damn, fuck you. You ain't trying to keep her safe. You're like, oh, distance makes the heart grow fonder. I'm gonna say, oh, I gotta protect you. You have to leave. You can't see me anymore. I don't know when you're gonna be able to see me again. Knowing all the well that if she was to leave and it all worked out fine, it's game over. It's game over for him. But he's like, no, you gotta go. I love you. And like waiting. She doesn't say it back. They eventually tire of having sex. The morning comes, she's gotta go. He's got her going down into the carriage again. Lucien at that point's like, what the fuck? You're so close. Why are you letting her leave? Lucien's like, just give her a couple more days. 'Cause Lucien knows she's so close to saying it back. Why would you say goodbye? And that's the thing too, is like Lucien has been pushing and supporting and catering. to Tamlin to like encourage him to spend time with Feyre, to be kind to Feyre, to love on Feyre, to be sweet to Feyre.
47:32 And Tamlin's just like a complete— Okay. You should compliment her. All right, let me do that. Yeah. You should go on a walk with her. All right, I guess I'll do that too. Like, yeah, 100%. 100%. So she's in the carriage. Lucien's trying to get him to keep her for a couple more days cuz they're so close. Cuz if, if the curse breaks, mind you, they're all free. Everybody that belongs to the Spring Court is free from this curse. All they need is for her to fall in love with him. Is everybody everybody? Uh, maybe cuz, cuz Amaretto wouldn't go away. He would just be free. No, you're right. Spring Court. Hopefully we'll have listeners tell us. Hey, leave a comment.
48:16 I'm just saying, like, how do we— yeah, I wanna, I wanna investigate how we can do that too, because I'm sure there will have lots of people to be like, y'all are fucking weird and gross. But also, I feel like there are going to be plenty of people that are gonna be like, you're wrong. Yeah, I want to hear what, like, our listeners have to say. But like, like, the whole Tamlin, Lucien, Rhysand And Amaretto, um, dynamics are so fucked up in this book. So fucked up. Like, my Spidey sense, my, my Spidey sense is like, girl, the boy don't fucking love you, okay? Like, go do your own thing. Go find something else that you can fuck. I mean, I Do they even have like vibrators back in that age? I don't know. I mean, her dad can whittle one out of wood.
49:16 I don't think I'd want that in my cooter, okay? That's splinters, okay? I can't see down there. Can you help me? I know, right? I need a series of mirrors and a couple of extra hands. You're in like— I just pictured one of those Mirror mazes, and you're yes, yes. I'm like exactly. I think I got it. Wait, where's my tweezers? Oh wait, you know I can't handle my own tweezers. I gotta have somebody else help me. I'm gonna need extra people. It's like you're gonna have to make it a family affair or something. And the next thing you know, you're fucking bald because you haven't even gotten the tick. Oh my god, we're going to have a tick, but fully bald now.
50:04 Man. So on. So, um, fuck, where did we leave off? Hey, what's up? Oh, oh, she's leaving. She's in the fucking carriage and he tells her again, I love you. And she's close. It's on the tip of her tongue, but she don't fucking say it. She goes back home. That's when like one of the most interesting for Nesta, in my opinion, occurs. She goes back home. She now sees that her family has lived a very wealthy life. They're in the beautiful home. They're no longer in the cottage. He has been taking care of her family this whole time. They have food. They have luxuries. They're, I mean, perfect, perfect life. She comes home.
50:45 Elaine, the dad, or the dad's out of town, so it's Elaine or something like that, and Nesta, and they're like, oh my God, you're home. Oh, the aunt died so that she hadn't been taken care of or whatever the fuck. There's this whole story. Yeah. And Feyre was going along with it only for us to find out that Nesta was never glamoured. Nesta always remembered that Feyre had been taken by this beast. And what do we learn? We learn that fucking Nesta goes back to the village to find that mercenary person that bought the wolf pelt. to hire her, to take her across the wall to search for Feyre.
51:28 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But anyway, anyways, like, she is a fucking little bitch, right? Like, yeah, she's a little bitch to Feyre, right? And she's like, um, but now she's all glamoured up, right? She's not in like the scraggly fucked up clothes she was in before Feyre left. And like, she doesn't have, um, she's not very, uh, what's that word I'm looking for? Appreciative of what they have now versus what they had prior, prior to Feyre being carted off to the Spring Court. Do you think it's 'cause she knows where it's coming from? Maybe.
52:18 Maybe, but it gets even more fucked up as, as we read the book because of shit that Amaretto does and things like that. Sorry. Yeah. I like that she didn't marry that guy that Farrah told her in those last few minutes. Don't marry so-and-so, he beats his wife or whatever. Yeah. Nessa listened. I thought that was interesting. I'm like, dang, she not only listened, but then she actually went to try to find her. Mm-hmm. She knew. Yeah. Like she had some sort of conscience or whatever. Yeah. Or maybe it was just to rub her fucking face in it. It's the, the interesting dynamic of her once she, once she got back to the house, right?
53:02 And seeing all this beauty and, you know, Elaine out there in her motherfucking garden, like just living her best life in these beautiful dresses and then like the, A big party that her dad had, right? Welcoming Pharaoh home. Yeah. Did you guys find it interesting that like her crippled dad all of a sudden was like out and about walking around? Yeah. Yeah. He's like, fuck that guy. I got money now. I got money around. I'm gonna go fucking spend it like it's the last thing on earth. I don't fucking care. We're so rich. We know we have 3 times what we had before. Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Yeah. I, I did like you listening cuz I'm starting to get Fucking spicy about him. I, I did like the conversations that Feyre and Nesta had in this book after she got back. I, I liked, yeah, I liked that Nesta was like, fuck our dad. He never, like, our mom was sick and he could have sailed. They had money. He could have sailed to find her a cure and he didn't. He let her die.
54:00 And so then you start to see like, oh, she really hates her dad. Yeah. Yeah. And, and in that conversation, I think it— sorry, side note, Feyre, Nesta says, tell me everything, cuz I was never glamoured. Feyre does. She tells her everything. Tells her about Tamlin, tells her about Lucien, tells her about the whole thing. So in that conversation of like the dad and the mom and her hate for it, I think is when, when Feyre understands a little bit more about Nesta and Nesta kind of inspires Feyre to go back. And to fight for her man. 'Cause Feyre realizes at that point, oh, I do love him. I should have said it. And like, he could be in trouble now. I need to go back. Yeah. But if you did that, then we wouldn't have 5 books later.
54:45 Sorry. If she would've said it in that moment, curse broken. Yeah. Curse broken. Tiny books. That would've sucked. Thank you, Sarah J. Maas. This is the part where I got hooked into the book is when I realized she's going back. That's when it got good.