Welcome to Paperback Confessions!
Aug. 19, 2026

A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, The Huntress Goes Full G.I. Jane and Makes a Dangerous Bargain, Pt 3

A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, The Huntress Goes Full G.I. Jane and Makes a Dangerous Bargain, Pt 3
A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, The Huntress Goes Full G.I. Jane and Makes a Dangerous Bargain, Pt 3
Paperback Confessions
A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, The Huntress Goes Full G.I. Jane and Makes a Dangerous Bargain, Pt 3

Feyre goes Under the Mountain in Part 3 of our spoiler-heavy A Court of Thorns and Roses breakdown, where deadly trials, Amarantha’s mind games, Lucien’s loyalty, and Rhysand’s dangerous bargain change everything. We unpack Feyre’s survival instincts, Tamlin’s continued uselessness, and the moment the huntress finally comes roaring back.

Spoiler Warning

Heads up, confessors: this is a SPOILER-HEAVY episode. We’re going Under the Mountain for Part 3 of our deep dive into A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, and the slow burn has officially been replaced by deadly trials, psychological torture, fairy wine, dangerous bargains, and Feyre going full G.I. Jane.

If you haven’t read A Court of Thorns and Roses, turn back now because we are absolutely not holding shit back.

The Book
  • Title: A Court of Thorns and Roses
  • Series: Book 1 of the A Court of Thorns and Roses series
  • Author: Sarah J. Maas
  • Spice / Heat: More tension than payoff, with fairy wine, body paint, questionable touching, and one very charged Tamlin encounter
  • Tropes: Deadly trials, morally gray fae, forced bargains, forbidden attraction, survival games, secret assistance, psychological torture, and one human woman doing everyone else’s damn job
The Confession

Welcome back to the feral little sister of Sh!t That Goes On In Our Heads.

Feyre heads Under the Mountain after Alis gives her some very simple advice: don’t drink the fairy wine, don’t make deals unless your life depends on it, and don’t trust anyone.

Naturally, Feyre eventually breaks most of those rules.

She finally meets Amarantha, forever known here as Amaretto, learns just how bad things really are, and discovers that saving Tamlin means surviving three deadly trials or solving a riddle she absolutely cannot figure out.

The first trial finally gives us the Feyre we’ve been waiting for. She stops trying to overpower the threat, starts thinking like the huntress she is, and uses her environment to survive a giant murderous worm.

Then Rhysand enters the equation in a much bigger way. When Feyre is badly injured and facing death, he offers to heal her in exchange for one week every month in the Night Court.

She makes the bargain.

And suddenly this whole story starts feeling very different.

Just the Tip

This week, Just the Tip is less about spice and more about survival.

Feyre’s trials show how resilience can look messy, uncomfortable, and deeply personal. The first forces her to adapt physically, while the second targets the thing she is most ashamed of: her inability to read.

That second trial hits hard because Amarantha isn’t attacking Feyre’s body, she is attacking her sense of worth.

And Feyre keeps going anyway.

What We Get Into
  • Alis finally revealing the truth about the curse
  • Feyre going Under the Mountain
  • Meeting Amaretto and learning Clare Beddor’s fate
  • The first trial and Feyre going full huntress mode
  • Lucien risking himself to help her
  • Rhysand’s bargain and the Night Court tattoo
  • The second trial weaponizing Feyre’s inability to read
  • Tamlin continuing to do almost nothing
  • Fairy wine, body paint, and Rhysand’s questionable motives
  • The psychological setup for the final challenge
Favorite Chaos Moments

G-Rex: “It was a fucked-up, R-rated Disney movie.”

G-Rex: “She was a tiny gnome butch. Kind of like me. I’m more of a flutch though.”

Dirty Skittles: “Beauty and the Beast if the Beast, Tamlin, was Gaston.”

Dirty Skittles: “As it turns out, she rubs shit all over herself.”

Nacho: “So what, Lucien’s Lumière?”

Nacho: “Where the fuck were you, beefcake? Get the fuck outta my face. I was dying.”

Our First Impressions

G-Rex is fully Team Feyre at this point. This is the version of her she has been waiting for, strategic, stubborn, resourceful, and willing to adapt when brute strength is not enough.

Dirty Skittles loves seeing Feyre reclaim the huntress she was at the beginning of the book, but her opinion of Tamlin keeps getting worse.

Nacho is finally getting the payoff they wanted after a very long setup and is paying close attention to every bit of Rhysand foreshadowing.

We all agree on one thing: Feyre may have gone Under the Mountain to save Tamlin, but the woman surviving these trials is becoming someone very different.

Subscribe, Rate & Review

Subscribe so you never miss an episode of Paperback Confessions, and rate and review us wherever you listen.

Every review helps more confessors find our messy little book club.

Visit www.paperbackconfessions.com for episodes, bookish chaos, morally questionable fictional people, and everything else we probably should not be saying into microphones.

Coming Up Next

The final challenge is here, and Amaretto is done testing Feyre’s strength.

Now she’s testing her humanity.

Three hooded figures. Three lives. And when the final hood comes off, Feyre has to decide what she is truly willing to sacrifice.

This episode proves one thing: the huntress is officially back.

#PaperbackConfessions #ACOTAR #ACourtOfThornsAndRoses #SarahJMaas #FeyreArcheron #Tamlin #Rhysand #Lucien #Amarantha #UnderTheMountain #NightCourt #FaeRomance #FantasyRomance #Romantasy #SpicyBooks #BookTok #Bookstagram #BookPodcast #RomancePodcast #MorallyGray



Where to Find Us

Website: https://www.paperbackconfessions.com

Instagram: @paperback_confessions

Paperback Confessions is the feral sister podcast to the award-winning Sh!t That Goes On In Our Heads, where we normalize conversations about mental health through honest stories, laughter, and real connection.

Discover more at: https://goesoninourheads.net

00:00 - Welcome to ACOTAR Part 3

00:43 - Alis Reveals the Truth and Warns Feyre

05:19 - Under the Mountain and Meeting Amaretto

08:25 - Three Trials or One Impossible Riddle

11:35 - Rhysand, Amaretto, and a Whole Lot of Foreshadowing

15:26 - Trial One, The Huntress Is Back

17:27 - Tiny Gnome Butch Survivalist Mode Activated

22:01 - Feyre Outsmarts the Murder Worm

24:11 - Tamlin Does Nothing, Lucien Risks Everything

28:17 - Feyre Is Dying and Rhysand Makes an Offer

29:09 - he Dangerous Night Court Bargain

32:23 - Feyre and Lucien’s Friendship Gets Real

33:47 - Trial Two Targets Feyre’s Deepest Shame

36:50 - Fairy Wine, Body Paint, and Tamlin’s Terrible Timing

39:32 - Rhysand Covers Tamlin’s Tracks

41:20 - Trial Three Becomes Psychological Torture

42:15 - Three Hooded Figures, Three Impossible Choices

43:45 - Rhysand Starts Revealing His Real Game

0:00 Hey, book besties! You're about to hear part 3 of our coverage of A Court of Thorns and Roses. The trials have begun, the stakes have never been higher, and Feyre is about to prove true strength isn't measured by power. It's measured by what you're willing to endure for the people you love. Grab your emotional support fairy wine and let's finish this shit.

0:43 Well, she sees this creature that's like made of what looks like bark and whatever. It's like rifling through all the things, going back and forth, and then all of a sudden it sees her and she's like, who are you? Do you know where all these people are? And she was like, I don't know. I don't know. Are you dumb, girl? It's me, it's Alice. And she's like, whoa. Yeah, because Alice is not glamoured anymore. And then Alice is also going through the house and looking for like whatever she can salvage. Yeah, ration, because she's taking that back to her sister's kids who she now adopted because the kids' parents were killed. And so she's like, you know, getting all this and she's telling Farrah to just leave. Like, this is not safe for you.

1:33 Yeah. And, but then she does give her instructions on how to, how to get to, um, Amaretto's cave and, and, you know, things to watch out for. And I think the funniest not funniest, but something that clicked in me and I had to go back and read this is like, don't drink the fairy wine. Yeah. Yeah. I was actually just gonna like see if I can find that, that piece, which I probably can't. But, uh, she does give, give her pretty clear guidance and instructions on shit that does go down while she's under there. Like how, like how to get there, how to, you know, what, what to do, what not to do, things like that. Right. And this is where I really saw, like, the butch lesbian energy come in for Feyre, 'cause she's like, I need to go save my man, or my woman, or whatever. But, like, she is, like, determined to go get her savior back. It's, it's kind of like a A savior complex. I kind of vaguely remember, but can I tell you, there was, I love Alice and I love her even more as the series goes on, but I did get mad at her when she was like yelling at Feyre in the kitchen. She's like, you dumb girl, you could have broken this curse. Cuz now at this point,

3:04 that timeline has hit. So now Alice can talk about the curse beforehand. Part of that curse was like nobody could tell Feyre anything about it. That was part of the deal. But now that that's happened, she's able to say like, the sickness in the land is actually Amaretto. You could have broken it if you would've just said you loved him. Like she tells her all the shit. Yeah. And like nobody gave her any clues or anything to say. Like, like you, you have to tell, tell him you, you love him. Like it was a fucked up, like. R-rated Disney movie. Okay. Yeah. That's the side quest. I'm like, if it was Beauty and the Beast, cuz a lot of people compare it to that. I'm like, yeah, Beauty and the Beast. If the Beast, Tamlin, was Gaston.

3:52 Yeah. I was like, ah, Beauty and the Beast. Gaston's that egotistical motherfucker. But, but like, who was gonna be the teacup? Was that gonna be Alice? Or the teapot? No, Alice would be the teapot. Yeah. Yeah. So what, Lucien's Lumiere? Yes. Alice, shout out MVP, takes Feyre to like some side door that only like the people who really know how to get around know about. So it like cuts her travel down by like a significant amount. Yeah. Tells Feyre some very strong parting words. I'm gonna paraphrase it. But basically tells her, don't drink the wine. Don't make any deals unless your life depends on it. Um, it's like she took the, the warnings and then immediately decided that number 1 on my list and number 2 on my list are gonna be exactly what Alice told me not to. A few rules to remember, girl.

4:51 Don't drink the wine. It's not like what we had at the solstice. and will do more harm than good. Don't make deals with anyone unless your life depends on it. And then, even then, consider whether it's worth it. Most of all, don't trust a soul in there. Not even your Tamlin. Your senses are your greatest enemies. They will be waiting to betray you. There you go. Yeah. So Feyre goes through this mountain, fast forward. Uh, she's like on her journey and a creature grabs Feyre and drags her ass straight up to Amaretto's throne and throws Feyre on the ground. And this is when it gets good because Feyre looks up for the first time. She sees Amaretto. Mm-hmm. Amaretto's kind of hot. No, red hair. She's, she's kind of hot. You know what she reminds me of is like— Dummy mommy. Yeah. Dummy mommy. Like. I could— I can imagine her in like leathers and a whip and like fucking like stockades and spiky dildos and shit like that.

6:01 Okay, she is a fucked up woman in more ways than one. Mm-hmm. And possessive as all fuck. Tamlin. Fuck that guy. Fucking Tamlin. Yeah, Tamlin. But like when we got to this part with like Amaretto and all the fucked up shit she did, then I started like getting more and more into the book and— Mm-hmm. Me too. I think it was like the trials, like, you know, Feyre's back and Amaretto's like, hmm, you want him?

6:41 You need to fight for him. And like, as she's at the throne and sees Amaretto, she sees Tamlin sitting next to Amaretto and Tamlin looks like he's— And he doesn't even anything. No reaction. It looks like he's— she's so bad so that Feyre thinks he's under a spell. He ain't. Newsflash, he's not under a spell. He's just not reacting because He doesn't want Amaretto to like hurt Feyre worse than she was probably already going, going to. Right. He wants to show no emotion and, and he succeeds. He shows no emotion. Uh, that's when Feyre discovers that Amaretto went to, went and got Claire thinking it was Tamlin. Claire and her whole family.

7:30 Tortures her. lights her on fire or something. She's still hanging there. Yeah. She is. She's still hanging there. I was like, what a fucking psycho fucking bitch. Bitter ass bitch. Yeah. She, I was like, when I was describing this to my mother-in-law before she read the series, I was like, and Tamlin has like this crazy ex-girlfriend, Amaretto. They never dated, but Amarantha wants Tamlin. She wants Tamlin to be her man. Do you think that she just wants him to like want him, or do you think she just wants the full collection? The full collection of 7 High Lords? Yeah, I do. Yeah. And I think she wants to, to control him. And now Feyre is there and she, for the first time, I think says, I'm here to claim Tamlin or some bullshit. She's like, this is the man I love. I want him. Mm-hmm. And, uh, Amaretto's like, well, let's play a game. Let's make a deal. Um, I think she says there are 3 challenges that you have to go through, and if you can succeed, then you can have him. Yep.

8:39 Or you can solve a riddle and free him and his, his town, his people immediately. Tells Feyre this riddle. Feyre's like, I don't know what the fuck the answer is. Yeah. Feyre's like, got me. I don't know. And apparently all the other fairies know and they're laughing at her cuz like, what a stupid human doesn't, can't solve this simple riddle. I'm the worst at riddles, buddy. That was me. I'm not figuring it out ever. What about you? Yeah, I wouldn't have. I, yeah, I'm like stupid when it comes to those things. Yeah. I honestly couldn't figure out what the, uh, what the, what it was until I got a little bit closer to the end of the book. And then I was like, okay, now, now I know what it, now I know what it is, but I'm not gonna say it yet until we get to that part. Yeah. Here it is.

9:42 There are those who seek me in a lifetime, but, but never we meet, and those I kiss who trampled me beneath ungrateful feet. At times, I seem to favor the clever and the fair, but I bless all those who are brave enough to dare. By large, my ministrations are soft-handed and sweet, but scorned, I become a difficult beast to defeat. For though each of my strikes lands a powerful blow, When I kill, I do it slow. Fuck if I know. Fuck if I know. Right, right. I think I'm poison. Right. Yeah. Feyre's like, okay.

10:22 She's like, well, so I can't even read your mood and you want me to have all these like fucking, fucking hell. Yeah, that's true. Feyre can't read and, and fucking Tamlin didn't try to help her. Nope. He's like, it's okay. Women don't need to read. Foreshadowing. Gee. Foreshadowing. A lot of foreshadowing. Yeah. So, um, Tara's like, oh shit, I gotta do these missions cuz I'm not fucking figuring this riddle out. Uh, has to like live, I think it's like 3 months. It's like one every 3 months. It's one full moon, one on the full moon. Oh, thank you. Okay. Thank you. There you go. So in the meantime, she has to basically stay up in like a fucking dungeon. Yeah. Yeah. So no hospitality.

11:11 Yeah. Yeah. And then Amerta's like, hospitality suite. No. Amerta's like, also while you're here, you need to earn your keep, so you might have to clean up a little bit. Vera's like, well, fuck me. The whole time trying to get just. any like glimpse of love from Tamlin and he's like, I don't know who she is. Never seen her a day in my life. Yeah. She pulls Rhysand. Yeah. She pulls Rhysand over. It's like, is this the, is this the girl or is that the girl? And Rhysand's like, I don't know. They all look the same. But I, but like all of these like tests that she did, and this is kind of where Rhysand becomes a little bit of a bitch. Yeah. He's a little fucking bitch.

11:59 Okay. Why? Explain. Well, because like he's still doing Amaretto's bidding. Mm-hmm. Right. Oh. Mm-hmm. And like, he, he could help her, but he's not. And he, he wants her, but he doesn't want her. I'm like, you're a dick. You either want her and you're gonna help her. Or you don't want her and just leave her the fuck alone. When you say want her, you mean like sexually? Yeah. He wanted her sexually. Rhysand wants Feyre? Yeah. Like all up in her business, you know, screaming, Mimi, gonna tie her wrists to the, the bed and call it a day. But like, it, it took a while for him to like kind of come around. So.

12:46 Oh, I think I, this is why I love that G hasn't read the rest of the fucking books because I gotta be honest with you, G. I did not pick up the I want her part. Mm-mm. I never, um, let me not even get into it cuz I don't want to ruin it, but I didn't pick that up in, in book one. Put a pin in this. Yeah. Foreshadowing. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Um, but they have a dynamic. So what, what is Rhysand and Amaretto's relationship? Uh, Rhysand is fucking her little bitch. Her little bitch. He fucked her a few times. Rhysand is Amaretto's little bitch. Yeah. Yeah.

13:28 Like, I, I 1 million percent agree. Amaretto is, is his dom. She, he is her little slave. Mm-hmm. I, I wouldn't be surprised if he's, you know, being cockblocked like every, every other night, but like, Rhysand has to do whatever Amaretto was telling him to do. And I don't know, he was kind of a fucking pussy. All right, like, stand up for yourself. Like, don't be a pussy. Because here you have Feyre, right? This little butch with a tiny bit of a femme streak in her. Yeah, full G.I. Jane mode. Yeah, full G.I. Jane mode. I'm gonna save my man. I'm gonna get this shit done. I'm gonna use my head if I don't have the physical strength. I can't read though. Yeah, in the meantime, Rosanna's like jerking off in the corner to be like, oh, just go take care of yourself and maybe we'll have sex later on. And then like when she goes to like the party tonight, right, he's making her drink this fairy juice that like fucks her the fuck up. I love it. It's kind of like somebody being roofied, okay? Like, what the fuck? Do you want— uh, okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. All right. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes. All the things. I'm with you 100%. Sorry. Not sorry.

14:52 Not sorry. Yes. They call Rhysand Amarantha's whore. Mm-hmm. That is his title. That's how people in the land know him to be, and that is the role he plays. He also is very powerful, right? So he's kind of her little minion because he can see and read people's thoughts and minds. Yes. She cannot, she does not have and possess that power. So Rhysand plays that part. I'm your whore. 100%, girl, you're beautiful. Love you. You want me to read somebody's mind? Say when. He does whatever she wants. Yes. Fast forward to the first challenge. What I really liked about this is it brings us back to that huntress, right?

15:34 Like that G.I. Jane we saw in the beginning of the book. She's back. The first challenge is like, I'm gonna fuck this up, but she basically is like running from this worm, earthworm eating fucking creature. Yeah. It's a crazy fucking thing that whatever was going after her. Yeah. I just imagine like a worm with an open mouth and like a bunch of little teeth and it's like fucking huge. Like Doom. Yes, yes, yes, yes. And so And then it's like in like a stadium. So everybody's sitting and looking down and watching, waiting to watch her die. Yeah. And instead of dying, she channels what she knows. Okay, I am gonna hunt.

16:17 And she immediately starts assessing where she's at. She's counting turns as she's running from this fucking thing. At one point she sees a little crack in a wall and to get away from this huge worm, she's gonna like try to get through this wall onto the other side and she gets stuck. She can't move forward. It's almost as if something is holding her back. Do you think it's just the mud or did you think something or someone was holding her? I felt like something was holding her back from being able to do the action. Yeah. Yeah. What about you, Nacho? I didn't pick up any of that. No, I was like, hey, I'm gonna be your nacho man. Um, squirrel. Uh, no, I didn't pick up on any of that. I was too into like, what's next? Oh my God, right? I like, when I get to that part of the book, I'm just like, yeah, she's a badass! Like, go! I hate that she's doing it for this asshole, but Yeah.

17:22 She's like really stretching her legs and maybe this is gonna go like a whole other way. Yeah. Yeah. I like saw her as like a butch survivalist. You know, she couldn't overpower the, the monster, so she just watched it and adapted. Oh, was she like a tiny gnome? She was a tiny gnome, but she used her environment. She was a tiny gnome butch. A tiny gnome butch. Kind of like me. I'm more of a flutch though, but like, I almost choked. I almost choked. I have, I have tears in my eyes that went through the nose and back down.

18:05 Oh no, you just cleaned your sinuses on the podcast live action. I'll pull the vodka thing now. The vodka. Wait, do I have more? I hope so. Where's the bottle? Are you gonna take a nap after this like you did the last time? Yes! It's still one. It's one drink. It's one pour from the same container. Into like a 12-ounce— wait, at least like a 16-ounce glass. No, but look at the pretty glitter. It is so cool. Yeah, so like the little garden gnome-sized butch survivalist, she just adapted, right? And even though she felt like she was being held back, but I loved what she did and like doing the skulls and the, and the bones and, and sticking them up so that like when the worm motherfucker came through, okay, he got skewered and now he's kebab. She hunted. Yeah. She said, you want me to be out here? Bet I'm gonna hunt this motherfucker down and kill it. I think she was held in the wall when she was trying to like squeeze through because that's when she realizes that this fucking worm is blind and it can only smell. Mm-hmm. And it's like once she had that thought and realized it, something let her go and she was able to go through the wall.

19:31 Yeah. And then like rubbing all that smelly gross— Oh, oh, I could almost smell it as I was reading the book. I'm like, ugh. 'Cause it's like mud and shit and piss and everything. And see, this is the part of the book that makes me ha— uh, accept the fact that I had to go 8,000 chapters in, in order to start loving this book because this last couple of chapters was just mind-blowing. Yeah. All Is Forgiven. This is when I was telling Jude, like when she couldn't get through it, I was like, just wait, you gotta get to this thing and it's gonna like, this is when it kicked in for me. And this is when it kicked in for me. So like from chapter 35 on, I could, I could deal with it. But these tasks are like reminding me of like some of the struggles like we all have to go through, right? Like, how do we get through it? Do we survive? To survive, what do we have to do? Do we adapt? Do we like do— Break it down into smaller pieces? Break— do we do shit that we typically wouldn't do, like rub shit all over ourselves? Okay, listen, I don't know. That is gonna be almost a super hard pass for me. I don't think I could do it because A, I have a horrible gag reflex, okay?

20:38 So I'm gonna be throwing up. up on myself all day long. Yeah. And number 2, like, I, I don't know if I could, if I would want that on my skin. But then, you know, fucking Rashand, even though she smells like a, you know, fucking toilet, he's like, hey girl, hey. I'm like, you're a dick. All right, listen, I smell like shit and now you wanna be like, hey girl, hey. Hold up, hold up. You done skipped like the best part of this shit is like, Um, she rubs the shit and piss all over herself. Yeah. Yeah. So she's rubbing the shit all over herself. How many times am I gonna say that? Say that one more time while I'm trying to take a drink. So as it turns out, she rubs shit all over herself. No, there's a market for that somewhere. No longer just a tip. Uh, I, we're gonna call it the whisper moment. The whisper moment. She, she rubs herself with shit. Yeah. 'Cause this book doesn't have a just a tip. There's no hot sex moment. Whisper into the mic.

21:42 Yes, she would. She rubs shit all over herself. Shit. She smells like a latrine. Like a latrine? Mmm, yummy. Makes me want to kiss her. As she's rubbing the shit on herself, fairies are like, ew, gross, what is she doing? And the only one that immediately knew was Rhysand. He goes, oh, she just became invisible. Yes. Because now she smells like this creature's shit. And so Feyre now is, she's in huntress mode. She's like, cool, you can't find me. She, what you were saying earlier, she like makes like a trap, like a snare trap of bones and like gross shit in this giant pit to like, for this worm to fall on. And then she's like, I'm not done yet.

22:35 I'm gonna now make a ladder out of these bones so that I can climb out after. She climbs out, she lures the fucking creature by cutting her hand. So now he could smell the blood. She runs and she had already been counting the turns, so she knew the exact path to get there. She jumps into the pit. The worm follows her. Bam. Gets snared by all these bones. In doing so, as she jumps down, she actually cuts her arm. Yeah. She's fine. She's like, that's cool. I could still make it out. Makes it out and half the crowd is cheering. Holy shit. That was the coolest thing we've seen. Amaretto's not pleased at all. Feyre's furious cuz now that hunter is inside of her and she went and like grabbed a bone and like just fucking darted it towards Amaretto in the stands and it lands right in front of Amaretto's feet.

23:23 So hot. So fucking hot. Like I was like, God. Damn, Feyre. I'm attracted to masculinity. So for me, I was like, holy shit. Amazing. I like that Amaretto is like, oh, you cost a lot of people a lot of money, but only one person made money on this. Rhysand. Rhysand made the money. He said she'll make it. That's when you, that you're right. That's when the dynamic changes a little bit because Rhysand's like, oh, I kind of like this girl. Like, she's a badass. She's gonna, you know, she'll do whatever it takes to survive, but she's doing it because she still like believes in her head that she loves Tamlin. Oh yeah. But here's the fucking thing with like Tamlin, right? Like now he's being a, he is being a big old pussy. He's sitting next to Amaretto on, on the stage and he's just all like, kind of like checked the fuck out. He's not even doing anything to help her out. Like, if you love somebody that much, get up off your fucking ass.

24:32 Stop being selfish. Well, if you thought that somebody was holding her in that little crevasse, I love it. Why wasn't it Tamlin? Yeah. Why was it? Why? It could have been Tamlin holding her in the crevasse. He could have literally fucking done anything, but Tamlin doesn't have the powers to hold her. But you don't know. Who at that moment in time, you don't for sure. For sure. You don't know. I only have a theory because I've read the whole series and now I'm back to one. Yeah. But yeah, yeah. I will say in terms of not helping her out, so Jeek doesn't know. She didn't know in terms of helping her out. Even fucking Lucien, God bless his heart, still catching strays, is like, to your left, because she didn't know where the worm was. He yells it out and risks his safety to help her. Tamlin didn't do shit. She didn't do shit. Now we, we could argue Lucien was ordered by Tamlin to help Feyre. Yeah, maybe. But I, I like to think that he did it on his own. But I just, I, you know, I just didn't like the way that like Tamlin didn't do fucking shit.

25:35 Like you professed your love for this woman, even though you're being held as a slave by fucking Amaretto and her psychotic um, dumb maneuvers, but you're just sitting there like a fucking, like, bump on a goddamn log and like, oh, my girl's hurt, but I can't really help her because I'm too— I'm feeling so sorry for myself. Listen, bitch, get up, find your fucking voice, and help her. Yeah, I'm gonna be completely wild on this, and I'm gonna say— I'm not saying it with my full chest, but I, I do want to say that Tamlin didn't help her cuz he didn't really, I mean, no, he did. He, he didn't want her to die, I suppose, but he didn't want her to die, but he was like, I don't think he thought she could get through this. So I think he thought like, oh, it's game over. Fuck it. What's the point? Yeah. Yeah.

26:29 Okay. But fuck, you love this woman, right? You, wow. You have fallen in love with this woman. He said he loved her. He did. He loved her multiple times. Not for any reason in particular. If you say you are, you are in love with this woman, fucking fight for her. Don't be like a fucking, like, oh, but that like speaks more to, but that speaks more to like Skittles' theory of like, it was just a fucking setup from word go. Yeah. It, it, that part of the book made me mad. I'm like, what a fucking dick. Yeah. But like, I'm like team Farrah right now because, yeah. We all are. Like, we're with her. When the worst part of her comes out and she's like kicking ass. Yeah. Even when she was all like fucking broken and shit. Yeah. And like, who, who fixed her up? Was that Lucien or was it Rhysand? Rhysand. It was Rhysand. Okay. Because she was almost dead. Yeah. And she kept waiting for Lucien and then Lucien just never came. He was pre-empted. Rhysand did. He died. By what was— do you guys remember what happens to Lucien? I mean, we find out after, but in that moment, like timeline-wise, He gets in trouble for yelling to your left. Yeah. And Amaretta, Amaretto, Amarantha orders his punishment to be delivered by fucking Tamlin. 'Cause Tamlin's like, please don't kill him. So Amaretto's like, cool, then you have to deliver all the lashes. Right. He had to, he gave Lucien like 50 lashes or something. And like, how fucking— Fucking Lucien catching strays. Like,

28:02 Gets his ass whipped by his best friend. By his best friend. Like, how fucking hard was that for both Tamlin and Lucien to, I don't know, like, fuck, man. Kind of hot though. Kind of hot. The thought of, yeah. So now Lucien's recovering. He can't go to Feyre right away cuz he's injured. He's trying to heal and, and be able to walk. I think the next time he sees her, he's like, I could finally walk after, like, that's how bad he got his ass whooped. So Rhysand shows up that night because she's dying, essentially. She's got a really bad infection from the cut on her arm and being covered in shit. And so she's, she's got a fever. I've never been more turned on by shit in my life. Feyre knows she's dying. She's like, I have a fever. I'm not gonna make it. Fuck. Right?

28:57 Yep. So Rhysand shows up and he's like, hey, Feyre, um, looks like you're gonna die, but I could, I could help you out. Yeah. And this is when she has to make that deal with Rhysand. Yes. Yeah. And she immediately says no, cuz she don't trust him. She's like, no, not, not from what I've seen. I'm not doing it. He's like, are you sure though? Are you sure? He's like, let me see your arm. Fucking squeezes it and makes it painful. Yeah. Yeah. Grabs the bone. He's like wiggling it around. He's like, are you sure? Are you double, triple sure? You ready to die right now? Yeah. Like, he's like, make it all go away. You've already done one. You've only got 2 more. Right. And, and I think Feyre, her at that moment, her life depends on it. But really, if she dies, who's gonna save Tamlin? So she's like, all right.

29:52 They bargain for one week a month to spend. She has to spend with Rhysand in the Night Court. Mm-hmm. And all Feyre has heard of the Night Court is like, it's a creepy place. It's basically where Amaretto based this entire— yeah. Culture chamber on is this Night Court. So she's like, this whole Under the Mountain is fashioned after the Night Court. Yeah. And Rhysand's like, I'd love to take you there. Wiggles her bone, causes her pain, but ultimately. Yeah. They hold hands, they like form, they like solidify the, the, the deal with the tattoo on her arm. So now she's marked and anybody who can see her, all of a sudden she's, this bitch got a tattoo, but she's healed and she doesn't die. She makes it to the next challenge.

30:36 Mm-hmm. And that's that next challenge, man. Fucking Lucian back at it. Fucking like, it pissed it, it like pissed me off. Because I think Amaretto realized that, uh, Feyre couldn't read. Yeah. Who do you think, how do you think she figured that out? I think Tamlin fucking told her. Right? Yeah. I, I think— 'Cause, 'cause Rhysand doesn't know until that challenge happens. He's like, oh, she can't read. That she can't read. And like, you know, she's trying to— Oh, but wait, can we go back? 'Cause after she gets healed. Mm-hmm. Lucien comes in. Yes. Yeah. And he's like, how dare you? Yeah.

31:19 Make a bond. Mm-hmm. A deal. And, and Feyre's just like, where the fuck were you, beefcake? Yeah. Get the fuck outta my face. I was dying. He's like, bitch, I couldn't walk. Tamlin done whooped my ass. He's like, I tried to get here as soon as I could. Tamlin might have been doing some other things too. You know, like, I'm just saying, like, I don't think it was that bad. I think he was healing, but I, I think he was just trying to wait for some of the heat to blow off. I don't think he was healing with, uh, really sarcastic air quotes here. I don't think he was healing that long. I think he had healed up fine, maybe a day.

32:04 Yeah. And then just was waiting for the right time. Yeah. The right time for the, like, the heat to die down on him. Mm-hmm. Maybe. But don't fucking be a dick and like tell her, how dare you, when she was just trying to fucking survive. Yeah. Oh my God. Sorry. We totally forgot something in the beginning. Do it. Amaretto says, what's your name? And Farrah doesn't wanna give the name. And then they grab Lucien and threaten to kill Lucien and Feyre then says, no, no, no, it's Feyre. It's Feyre to save Lucien. So I, I bring that up now cuz I think to some degree that changes their dynamic. And now Lucien, I wonder how much of him helping her is because he cares about her. Like, you saved my life. I need to help you out. I think they really made like a connection and a friendship at the Spring Court. Yeah. I think that like, I think that like at the spring court before she got kicked out back to her family, like the whole cereal story, I think they were like— Homies. Yeah. Like sarcastic.

33:10 Okay, maybe you're not such a shithead and let's be friends. Like, you know, a tentative friendship there. And I feel like that friendship just sort of bloomed. And, and so I think that there's history there for that. for that idea that, that they are already friends and that they do care for each other. Maybe not romantically, but definitely care for each other. Yeah. He's loyal, you know? He, yeah, he is loyal, but I think that all kind of plays into like that second challenge, right? Poor Lucien. Fucking second challenge. Do you, do you wanna walk us through it?

33:51 Yeah. So like, Lucien is chained, right? And like this challenge, Feyre has to read out, like figure out a riddle or whatever. And as she's like trying to go through it, like these walls of spikes are coming down onto like Lucien and she's struggling, right? And it's multiple choice. And it's multiple choice. And I think that like the fucked up, like mental healthy part of this is that it was making Feyre feel shameful that she couldn't read. And like the fucking bitch Amaretto, she, she didn't fucking care. 'Cause she was strong. She was strong. But like Feyre is more strong-willed. than Amaretto thinks of her, right? Mm-hmm. She, you know, this butch lesbian energy of like, I'm gonna show you, motherfucker. I might be short and scraggly and whatever the fuck you think I am, but I'm gonna figure this out. But, you know, this is kind of where people would come in and, like, help her, and she was becoming way more observant and strategic as she got through this challenge. And I think it fucked up Amaretto.

35:15 When, um, she was able to complete it. Yeah. Well, how do you, how do you think she was able to complete it if she couldn't read? I think she was taking cues from like Lucian, um, as like she would like try and figure out what to try and read what was on the screen. Yeah. He's raising her arm. Yes, Nacho. go before you fall out of your chair? I think it was because she was using the hand with the mark. I think it was Rhysand who was using the mark to create pain at the ones that— at the different levers that were wrong. Because she tried, she tried the, the— she put her hand close to one of them and it was, uh, Uncomfortable, and then she put it next to uncomfortable. And then however it went down, like the one that was the right one, it was fine. And I think that he used the mark, the connection that he made with the mark to give her pain to say, no, this is not the right one. But I also think that this was the hardest and cruelest challenge for Farrah because it targeted the one thing that she was already deeply ashamed of.

36:34 Yeah. And the fact is that she didn't know how to read. Yes. 1 million percent. Yeah. Her feelings. How motherfucking fucked up was that? Her feelings of inadequacy were like, oh, heartbreaking. Yeah. I felt for her in that moment. Oh yeah. I will say like after that, that second challenge and before the third challenge is when she gets that tiny bit of time with, uh, Tamlin. It was kind of hot. It was kind of hot. Still think, you know, he's such a fucking coward though. He is. What a coward. What a pussy. What a fucking pussy. He's nasty. Yeah. The only time he fucking connects with her or like acknowledges her presence is when he wants to fuck her in like the back room of his party. Yep. Yeah.

37:20 But piece of shit. Hadn't she already had some more of that fucked up like fairy wine too? Yes. And you had said something earlier where it was like he was like date rape drugging her recently. Yeah, it was like she was— Roofing. Roofing her. Yeah. Um, question for you. Yes. He would have her body painted so he knew where he touched. Yes. And when she would wake up from those like roofied moments, she could see where he touched. Yeah. And it was always in innocuous places. It wasn't— Like her hips. It wasn't. Yeah, it wasn't her titties or her ass. Yeah. Yeah. It was always in like reasonably respectful considering the circumstances places.

38:02 Yeah. So while she may have been dancing on his lap and he's playing that part of like, this is just a, just a whore, right? Like, like he had no feelings for her. She always knew where he touched her. Yeah. Because she could see it. That's my theory anyways. Yeah. Yeah. It was more of a. She's more of a, more of a plaything than, yeah, than a lover or, you know. And I think he did that. Okay. This is foreshadowing, but I think he did that for her own peace of mind. I do too. I do too. But we can't say that because she can't know that. I, I, I, I know nothing. 100%. I do. I, I think that paint was more for her than it was for him to know where anybody touched her. And the reason the paint comes up is cuz in the hot scene where Tamlin is like basically getting ready to fuck her against a wall, he smears paint all over her. Yeah. And then, and then what has to happen? Rhysand has to come in and smear the paint. Looks like he's smearing the paint. And cleans Tamlin, cleans the paint off of Tamlin. Yep. So he doesn't get in trouble. Tells Tamlin, you better get the fuck outta here now.

39:11 You got like 0.2 seconds to like Balance buddy. Yep. And then he just goes to town with Feyre. Yeah. Which also like foreshadowing for like 3 books in a row, but we're coming back to this in like 45 episodes. Lucien survives yet again. God bless his heart. Um, fucking Tamlin still didn't help. Piece of shit. They go to an afterparty. Tamlin tries to fuck Feyre. Rhysand saves them, covers their shit. Yeah. Part of that scene where he is like kissing up on her and stuff, I do wonder, was it really to make it look like that?

39:52 Or I think it kind of, or I think it kind of pissed him off. Oh yeah. Oh, definitely. Oh, definitely. So I think he was like, oh, I'm gonna have fun in this moment. I'm gonna still be respectful. Okay. I am here for he did it and he was pissed about it because he didn't get to be the first one. He didn't get like, he's having to cover fucking Tamlin, that piece of shit. Yeah. Because, and he doesn't get to do it the way he wants to do it. No. He doesn't get to touch her the way he wants to touch her because he's gotta cover Tamlin's fucking dirtbag tracks. But also, but also he knows she enjoyed it. That's what she wants. Yeah, yeah, I know, I know. And, and he doesn't get to be kissing her when he wants to and how he wants to. And she's not looking at him in the way that she's looking at Tamlin. Yes. It's too much foreshadowing.

40:53 Too much. Yep. Yep. So people are trying to help her through this outside of Tamlin. Yeah. Outside of Tamlin. Fuck that guy. Because like everybody hates Amaretto. Even Lucien's mom hates Amaretto. Amaretto's like the dictator. And like how all the other, um, people from the high courts were all in this underground mountain cave. Yeah, prisoners basically. Bullshit. Like, uh, y'all are my slave camp. But I, that's like, that like made me think about like, okay, she's not in this on her own. People are trying to help her, blah, blah, blah. Um, but then we get to the fucking third challenge and girl, okay, listen, it kind of broke my heart, bitches. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. It broke my heart and then it, I also like cheered. So yeah, cuz I'm a little fucked up that way. It was psychological torture. Yeah.

41:53 And that, I think that's worse than sometimes worse than physical torture. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. It's equally detrimental. You, yeah. They're both terrible. You can't, I don't think you can say one is worse than the other. I don't know. I don't know. Maybe you can. Yeah. I think it's just a different pain. Yeah. It's different. I, I, and then like that third challenge is like, there's like these 3 hooded people. And Amaretto's like, you have to kill them. Mm-hmm. And so she, but, but like, she can't see who it is until she gets ready to like reach for the knife. And so like the first fairy is like, he's male, right? And she doesn't wanna kill him. Young.

42:44 Young. But she believes that completing that challenge will free Tamlin and everyone trapped under that mountain. And so she stabs him. One for many. One for many. And then like the second fairy, right? This one is, I believe it's a woman, right? And it really tugs at her heartstrings of having to, to stab this woman because she wanted to know more about her. Like, what did she do wrong? She stabs him. And then you get to the third hooded person. hooded thing. They take the hood off and it's Tamlin. And like, that's when like I had to go back and read like, um, back another part of the book about how Tamlin's heart was made of stone. Like, and then I remembered like if she stabs him, he's not gonna fucking die.

43:42 Yeah, there's a lot of layers to that scene. To that challenge. Yeah. There's a lot happening cuz that's the main thing. That's the 3 people she has to kill. Rhysand meets with her and tells her tomorrow's the final challenge. And he, he basically tells her and kind of confesses a bit. It means more than just her rescuing her love. And Rhysand kind of reveals the cards that he's been holding, which is, you know, essentially